Tuesday, October 18, 2011

Back To Life, Gilad Shalit


20.37 Richard Spencer, who has been in Mitzpe Hilareporting on the amazing scenes of the day, looks at Shalit's last 24 hours and the 'rebirth of a son', as his father Noam Shalit, put it:
No one knew how he had stood up to the rigours of solitary confinement. He was also injured by shrapnel during his kidnapping.
He fell ill during his first helicopter ride, and there were fears he would have to be taken straight to hospital. But though said to be suffering from malnutrition and lack of sunlight, he was passed fit to travel on.
His frailty highlighted the irony that it was the bookish and shy Gilad Shalit who had been seized. "He's quiet," said Avishay Mazor, 26, another friend. "He doesn't bother anyone, not even a fly. He just wanted to be left in peace, like his family."
20.31 Stephen Adams, the Telegraph's Medical Correspondent, writes that the last five years will have had a negative impact on his health. Shalit struggled to breath during a TV interview, and Israeli military officers said he showed signs of malnutrition. One British expert, Dr Walter Busuttil, medical director at the chairty Combat Stress, who helped treat British captives Terry Waite and John McCarthy said it could take him years to recover.
QuoteIf I was looking at him now I would be asking him about his sleeping patterns and meals, as these would both have been interrupted by his incarceration...
The first thing I would give him is a watch, to give him back a sense of control over time.
That's the first thing that would have been taken away from him...
19.45 Daniel Taub, the Israel's UK ambassador, writes forThe Telegraph that Shalit's return is a testament toIsrael's love of life.
At its root, the decision to make the deal was not won by pragmatic arguments or realpolitik. We are bringing Gilad home, and paying the painful price, not because we know that this is the correct strategic decision, but because of our profound conviction that it ought to be. The bittersweet joy of the moment presents a challenge to us all. If this indeed is not a world in which placing supreme value on a single human life is the best course of action, then let us work to make it one.
19.30 The Telegraph's Adrian Blomfield has more on Palestinian militants vowing to abduct a "new Gilad Shalit" to use as leverage against the Jewish state.
For optimists, the exchange represented a moment of hope that perhaps, after years of bitterness, the end of so painful a saga could mark the beginning of a new era in Israeli-Palestinian relations. Prompted by his Egyptian interviewer, Sgt Maj Shalit claimed to share such optimism, saying: "I hope this deal will lead to peace between Palestinians and Israelis and that it will support cooperation between both sides".
18.18 Other former captives have warned that coping with liberty again can prove emotionally difficult. Shalit himself earlier said that he was "on edge" after not having seen people for such a long time.
Mickey Zeifa, an army reserve coloneol held as a prisoner of war by Egypt in the 1973 Middle East War told Yedioth Ahronoth newspaper Shalit will require careful management.
QuoteIt takes a very long time for a person to get back on course ... you mustn't crowd him...
In my case ... the celebrations around me, which at first were flattering and moving, brought me down. Sometimes the return is a trauma in and of itself, no less difficult than captivity.
18.00 Egyptian prime minister Essam Sharaf has hailed the prisoner swap, which was mediated by Cairo, saying it was part of efforts to boost regional stability. He stressed these objectives "will be achieved through a just and comprehensive solution to the Palestinian question."
17.36 Barack Obama, via his spokesman Jay Carney, has said he was "personally pleased" that Shalit had been freed, adding that he wants Israelis and Palestinians to take steps toward resuming peace negotiations.
QuoteEach side needs to take steps that make it easier to return to negotiations rather than harder.
17.18 Noam Shalit, Gilad's father has addressed a crowd outside their family home. He thanked the Israeli government, Benjamin Netanyahu and the IDF as well as activists campaigning for his son. He said that his son, while very happy to be home, found it hard to be exposed to the big crowds of lots of people after being alone and isolated for so many days, where he could not communicate to anyone in his language.
He said his son will go through rehabilitation, with the help of the IDF, adding "we hope he can go back to a normal life." He also revealed that his son was suffering from afew shrapnel wounds and complications due to a lack of sunlight.
QuoteWe are today finishing a long journey, a tiring and long journey that started in June 2006 ...
As you saw today, he came back, went down the stairs came into the house through the door which he left so long ago...
Gilad is feeling well. He has a few light wounds... shrapnel wounds... also complications due to lack of sunlight.
Today we can say that we've gone through a rebirth of a son. I would like to thank the whole crowd, the public who gathered here today. You came to support Gilad with such a warm turnout, supporting in solidarity...
Unfortunatly Gilad will not be able to come out, but thanks to the pilot of the chopper who brought us here who flew twice over the village. Gilad looked down and waved at the crowds...
We would like to take this opportunity to thank the Israeli government, the prime minister, who took this hard decision, not an easy one unfortunately. I must say that even for us this deal was not easy.
As we stood yesterday at the court with the bereaved families, we sympathise with them, we understand their pain. We understand the price they are paying for Gilad's freedom...
We hope that this great crowd and the media will understand us and will let us go back to our normal lives as soon as possible...
When I met Gilad I didn't say much, I just gave him a big hug, and I said if I remember correctly 'Welcome', but mostly a strong hug.
Noam Shalit, father of Gilad, speaks outside the family home in northern Israel

Gilad Shalit, FREE AT LAST!





Sergeant Shalit, the first captive Israeli soldier returned home alive in 26 years, was interviewed on Egyptian television before being handed over to Israel. Sitting in a blue checked shirt and speaking Hebrew, he smiled and reflected on the questions before answering them.
Asked if he had feared that he would never get out, Sergeant Shalit answered that he worried it would take many more years although in the past month he had suspected a deal was in the works. He said he was told of his release a week ago.
Asked what he missed most in prison, he replied, “My family and my friends and seeing and talking with people. The worst was having to do the same thing every day over and over.”
He was told that Israel still had thousands of prisoners and was asked if he would like them released. “I will be happy for them to be released if they don’t return to fight us,” he said. “I very much hope that this deal will advance peace.”
Egyptian television showed Sergeant Shalit being rushed through the Rafah crossing terminal from Gaza into Egypt accompanied by Hamas and Egyptian officials.
Soon afterward, an Israeli military statement said: “Gilad Shalit crossed the border into Israel, ending over five years in captivity.”

Tuesday, October 11, 2011

Possible Deal Near to Free Gilad Shalit


Possible Deal Near to Free Captive Israeli Soldier
Published: October 11, 2011
JERUSALEM -- The Israeli government was due to meet in emergency session Tuesday to discuss a proposal to exchange Palestinian prisoners for an Israeli soldier who has been held captive by Hamasfor more than five years, a senior Israeli official said.

The official said all 29 ministers had been summoned for the meeting concerning the fate of the captive soldier, Staff Sgt.Gilad Shalit, and that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu viewed the proposal on the table as serious. He said the cabinet was expected to vote on the proposal.
Al Arabiyya, the satellite network, was reporting that Egyptian mediators had made a breakthrough and that the exchange for Sergeant Shalit could happen as early as November. 
One Israeli official said that Mr. Netanyahu had already met with his most senior ministers to review the names of hundreds of Hamas prisoners to be released.
Sergeant Shalit was seized in a cross-border raid by Hamas and other Palestinian militant groups in June 2006, and was taken into Gaza. He was 19 at the time, and efforts to end his prolonged incarceration in Gaza have become an emotional cause in Israel.
Hamas won Palestinian parliamentary elections in 2006 and then took full control of Gaza in 2007, routing the Palestinian Authority forces loyal to President Mahmoud Abbas of the rival Palestinian group Fatah.
A prisoner exchange deal had seemed close in late 2009, but the talks collapsed. Israel and Hamas each accused the other of failing to reach agreement. Israel has expressed readiness for a prisoner exchange, but has in the past balked at releasing some of those demanded by Hamas, including those whom Israel has convicted as planners and perpetrators of some of the deadliest terrorist attacks in recent years.
Two years ago, Israel released 20 Palestinian women from its jails in exchange for a videotape of Sergeant Shalit that proved he was alive.
The Israeli government is under constant pressure to arrange the soldier’s release. Despite the popular support here for some kind of a deal, many also have qualms about releasing some of the most notorious prisoners.
Tens of thousands of Israelis joined the Shalit family in the summer of 2010 for parts of a 12-day march from their home in northern Israel to Jerusalem to draw attention to their son’s plight. Since then, the soldier’s parents have spent many of their days in a tent on a sidewalk near the prime minister’s residence.

Thursday, October 6, 2011

Hank Williams Jr. should not have been fired.


Hank Williams Jr. should not have been fired.
We should all strive to engage each other’s intellect in a more productive way, and kindness is a quality endorsed by most civilizations, it should be encouraged.
However, free speech, within, for the most part, reasonable limits, really is the bedrock of the U.S.
If it is Hank Williams Jr.’s opinion that President Obama is as evil as a man who murdered millions of other human beings, that’s his opinion.
Speech, however, has consequences; not legal consequences, at least not in this case, but social, civil consequences.
You or I would be within our rights to stop listening to Hank Williams Jr.’s music.
Personally, I disagree with him.

I’m trying to assess Barrack Obama and what he is doing as President.
I’ve read his books; I’ve listened to his news conferences.
I’m reluctant to say  “He’s a mystery wrapped in an enigma”, but he is.
We have to remember when judging the man that he can’t necessarily always do exactly as he would like.
How much influence he personally has on policy is still being debated.
Still, even if one takes the position that Afghans and Arabs and Americans killed by our forces are President Obama’s responsibility on a personal level, he still is not  comparable to Hitler who, as we all know, systematically murdered millions of people.

Firing someone for having an unpopular, even outrageous view doesn’t seem to be consistent with a media outlet that should have the utmost concern with protecting everyone’s free speech.

Hank Williams Jr., in addition to being controversial, is an extremely talented singer and song writer.
I don’t agree with Williams or his views, but he has apologized, and he is entitled to his opinion.

“Williams issued a statement Monday night insisting his remarks were misunderstood, then apologized Tuesday.  
Among his defenders were Whoopi Goldberg and Joy Behar of "The View," who have a very different political viewpoint from the conservative Williams, but often are called out for their own comments.
‘Those among us who are without sin, cast the first stone,’ Goldberg said.




The Chomsky Hoax

The Chomsky Hoax
Exposing the Dishonesty of Noam Chomsky